Geometry-dependent rank defect in $C^1$ cubic spline space

Determining the dimension of the $C^1$ cubic spline space $S_3^1(\mathcal{T})$ on an arbitrary nondegenerate planar triangulation has remained unresolved since the 1970s. Schumaker's lower bound includes a local correction $σ$ for singular interior four-stars, and it was conjectured that this bound is always attained. We disprove this conjecture by constructing a one-parameter family of nondegenerate realizations of a fixed 18-triangle complex, with only the central vertex moving as $v_6(t)=(t,0)$ on the admissible interval $I=(-3/4,24/55)$. The family exhibits three distinct cases. For $t\in I\setminus\{1/5,3/83\}$, the lower bound is attained and $\dim S_3^1(\mathcal{T}(t))=33$. At $t=3/83$, the central four-star is singular, $σ=1$, and the resulting dimension 34 is exactly accounted for by the classical local correction. At $t=1/5$, however, all interior vertices are nonsingular and $σ=0$, yet $\dim S_3^1(\mathcal{T}(1/5))=34>P_{\mathcal{T}(1/5)}(1,3)=33$. The smoothing-cofactor calculation shows that the dependence at $t=3/83$ is confined to the central vertex block, whereas the dependence at $t=1/5$ couples all seven interior vertex cycles even though every individual block has full row rank. A complementary Bernstein--Bézier calculation gives the same dimension profile. Thus the singular-four-star correction does not capture every geometry-dependent contribution to $\dim S_3^1(\mathcal{T})$; genuinely global compatibility must also be taken into account.