Yining Wang
Prompted attribute agreement is widely used as evidence of text-to-music controllability, yet a requested attribute may occur simply because it is already common in the model's output distribution. We introduce a matched counterfactual evaluation that separates target occurrence from instruction-attributable control. Each family contains a neutral input that omits the scored attribute and two otherwise matched inputs that swap the requested target. All three are rendered through frozen native-interface adapters with a shared seed. Applied to global key and beat grouping in three open systems, this design changes the empirical conclusion. ACE-Step 1.5 and Stable Audio 3 Medium exhibit substantial key control, whereas LeVo2 does not. For beat grouping, the same models redirect toward the rare three-beat target, but high four-beat agreement is largely inherited from neutral outputs: Stable Audio 3 produces four-beat grouping in 0.97 of neutral cases but only 0.56 under its explicit four-beat treatment. Off-attribute placebos, external recognizer validation, blind expert annotation, and multi-seed sentinels support the attribution. When targets have unequal output priors, agreement describes what a model produced, while matched neutral and target-swap contrasts test whether the instruction changed it.