Patient-to-patient phenotype matching enables rare disease gene prioritization beyond curated gene-phenotype associations

Diagnostic tools for rare diseases typically rely on curated gene-phenotype associations and static disease models, limiting their effectiveness in cases with atypical presentations or previously uncharacterized disorders. To address these limitations, we present SimPheny, a phenotype-first algorithm for gene prioritization that operates independently of documented gene-phenotype associations. SimPheny identifies phenotypically similar diagnosed patients by comparing an undiagnosed patient's disease presentation to a reference cohort of diagnosed cases, and returns gene hypotheses by matching the undiagnosed patient's candidate gene list to the causative genes of similar patients using a statistical scoring model. Evaluated in diagnosed probands from the Undiagnosed Diseases Network (UDN) with the true diagnostic gene blinded, SimPheny consistently ranked the diagnostic gene among the top five candidates, outperforming existing tools, particularly for genes with limited gene-phenotype association data. When applied to previously unsolved UDN cases, clinical review confirmed that SimPheny's high-confidence causative gene predictions were diagnostic in nearly half of the analyzed cases. As the size of the diagnosed reference cohort increases, SimPheny's diagnostic reach expands without sacrificing ranking performance. By leveraging real patient data rather than curated models, SimPheny provides a generalizable, scalable framework for improving diagnostic yield in rare disease cohorts.