Armin Ahmadi, Jorge Gamboa, Sili Fan, Gwenaelle Begue, Brian J Bennett, Leila R Zelnick, Ian H de Boer, Bethany P Cummings, Baback Roshanravan
Metabolomic responses to OGTT and clamp were largely directionally concordant but differed in magnitude, with attenuation during OGTT. Discordant metabolites were rare, while non-corresponding metabolites were confined to amino acid pathways. CKD modified OGTT-clamp correspondence for metabolites involved in amino acid and glycolytic metabolism.
BACKGROUND: The oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT) captures integrated physiological responses involving intestinal glucose absorption, incretin signaling, and endogenous insulin secretion, whereas the hyperinsulinemic-euglycemic clamp (clamp) isolates insulin-mediated glucose uptake. Comparing plasma metabolomic responses to these two challenges may identify processes specific to intestinal nutrient delivery and how they vary in CKD.
METHODS: Targeted plasma metabolomics was performed in 59 adults without diabetes (39 with CKD [eGFR <60 mL/min/1.73 m2] and 20 controls) from the Study of Glucose and Insulin in Renal Disease (SUGAR). Each participant underwent a 75-g OGTT and clamp approximately one week apart. Eighty-eight plasma metabolites were quantified at fasting and during each challenge. Metabolite levels were log-transformed and normalized using Systematic Error Removal Using Random Forest (SERRF). Metabolites were classified using adjusted regression slopes relating OGTT and clamp responses.
RESULTS: The mean (SD) age and eGFR were 64 (13) years and 54 (26) mL/min/1.73 m2, respectively, and 41% were female. In the overall cohort, OGTT and clamp induced broad plasma metabolic changes, with 63 (72%) and 76 (86%) metabolites significantly altered from fasting, respectively. Seventy-three metabolites (83%) demonstrated a significant relationship between OGTT and clamp responses. Of these, 22 (25%) exhibited true concordance and 51 (58%) demonstrated similar directional changes but differed in magnitude. A total of 15 (17%) metabolites were discordant or non-corresponding, of which only three were discordant. The non-corresponding metabolites were enriched in amino acid metabolism. Eleven metabolites (13%) demonstrated differential responses between OGTT and clamp by CKD status, involving amino acid and glucose metabolism pathways.
CONCLUSIONS: Metabolomic responses to OGTT and clamp were largely directionally concordant but differed in magnitude, with attenuation during OGTT. Discordant metabolites were rare, while non-corresponding metabolites were confined to amino acid pathways. CKD modified OGTT-clamp correspondence for metabolites involved in amino acid and glycolytic metabolism.