A Comparative Study on Situation Awareness While Reading in a Highly Automated Vehicle

When driving a partially automated vehicle, maintaining situation awareness is essential for users to be better prepared to take over. A primary challenge is maintaining awareness while the user is occupied with another task without tunneling attention towards individual elements. To investigate this, we conducted an experimental study in our driving simulator (n = 20) comparing an indirect LED (light-emitting diode) visualization of relevant objects in the driver’s field of view with a combined condition of an indirect LED + direct HUD (head-up display) visualization. The participants’ situation awareness scores were higher under the combined condition. However, the scores dropped significantly for objects outside the LED + HUD visualization. We conclude that the indirect object indication is not effective in countering tunneling effects from the HUD, and neither does it provide a satisfactory trade-off when deployed on its own, i.e., without direct indication in addition.