Comparative Analysis of Physicochemical Properties and Agronomic Performance of Different Vermicompost Feedstocks

Vermicomposting is an environmentally sustainable, economically viable, and agronomically valuable method for converting organic waste into nutrient-rich soil amendments, thereby supporting sustainable development. However, the fertilization efficiency of vermicompost can vary significantly depending on the physicochemical properties of the feedstock used. This study aims to compare different feedstocks on vermicompost and evaluate their performance on soil fertility and plant nutritional status. Organic matter (OM), pH, salinity (EC), total Kjeldahl nitrogen (TKN), total phosphorus (TP) and total potassium (TK) of various vermicompost samples were taken into consideration to evaluate their fertilization efficiency as performance determinants in terms of plant growth, plant nutritional status, yield, crop quality and cost with the aim of determining the weights of the specific parameters in the total performance using multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) methods. The integrated ENTROPY-TOPSIS method was used. Twenty-one different vermicompost feedstock analyses were collected from the literature and compared in order to create an agronomic performance ranking based on the selected criteria. The ENTROPY method revealed that the TP was the most influential factor (21.6%), followed by the EC (20.7%) and the TK (18.5%), while the OM had the lowest impact (11.3%). Based on the TOPSIS ranking, vermicompost from brewer’s spent grain achieved the highest performance, followed by cow manure plus rice straw and olive pruning waste, whereas paper waste ranked at the bottom. A comparative analysis with other objective MCDM weighting methods proved strong correlations, particularly with WENSLO, MPSI and LODECI methods, confirming the robustness of the ENTROPY method.