The Impact of Automation on the Efficiency of Port Container Terminals

The increasing need to optimize efficiency in port container terminals has led to the transition of operations from manual to automated or semi-automated processes. Automation involves integrating or gradually adopting digital technologies and equipment that reduce human intervention, enhance productivity, safety and sustainability. This study investigates the impact of automation on port efficiency through a comparative analysis of 20 container ports in the wider Mediterranean region, using a two-stage modeling approach. In the first stage, Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) is applied under constant and variable returns to scale to estimate port efficiency using infrastructure, equipment, and container throughput data. The second stage employs Tobit regression to assess the effect of automated operations or systems on port efficiency, including variables such as the automation index, TEUs per employee, TEUs per ship (call) and revenue. A key contribution of this study is the development of a methodological framework for qualitatively classifying and evaluating these ports based on their level of automation, the introduction of digital technologies or equipment, and investments in new technologies. The results indicate that automation alone does not necessarily lead to higher efficiency unless it is effectively integrated into operations accompanied by adequate staff training and supported by gradual investment strategies. By contrast, cargo intensity (TEUs per call), highlights the importance of vessel size and cargo concentration in improving port performance.