Marlene A Rodríguez-Barragán, Fabiola M Palomino-Ramos, Wendy M Torres-Serrano, Aída Barrera-Ortíz, Ana V Aguirre-Güemez, Virginia Bueyes-Roiz, Ivett Quiñones-Urióstegui, Alberto I Perez-San Pablo, Paris Jo Velasco-Acosta, Gabriela García-Robledo, Verónica Enríquez-Vázquez, Cynthia E Calderón-Campos, Jimena Quinzaños-Fresnedo
Kayak ergometer training showed trends toward greater improvements in trunk control, functional independence, and cardiovascular fitness compared with conventional exercise, although differences were not statistically significant after Bonferroni correction.
CONTEXT: To determine the effect of kayak ergometer training on trunk control, cardiorespiratory condition, and independence in individuals with a SCI.
DESIGN: Randomized clinical trial.Setting: Third-level hospital.
PARTICIPANTS: Individuals with SCI with a neurological level of C8 or below, and 3-12 months since injury.
INTERVENTION: A control group received conventional trunk training, and an experimental group received kayak ergometer training. Both groups received five weekly sessions over six weeks.
OUTCOME MEASURES: Neurological status (ISNCSCI), independence (SCIM-III), Trunk Control Test (TCT), life satisfaction (LISAT-9), and a stress test were performed before and after the training.
RESULTS: 39 individuals were included and randomized to either a conventional trunk training group (n = 18) or an experimental group receiving kayak ergometer training (n = 21). In the experimental group, three participants were eliminated. Therefore, 36 participants completed the study and were included in the data analysis (control: 18; experimental: 18). The majority were men (>72%) with complete injuries, and the majority had lower thoracic injuries (58.4%). At the final measurements, all participants showed improvement in all outcomes following the intervention. We found significant improvements in SCIM-III (p = 0.047) and estimated VO2 (p = 0.045) in the kayak training group, findings that were not statistically significant after Bonferroni correction. Furthermore, compared with the group that received traditional trunk training, the kayak training group showed a trend toward faster, more effective improvement.
CONCLUSIONS: Kayak ergometer training showed trends toward greater improvements in trunk control, functional independence, and cardiovascular fitness compared with conventional exercise, although differences were not statistically significant after Bonferroni correction.