Geir Bjørklund, David Watts
Hair Fe and Mn concentrations were strongly and positively associated in this pediatric ASD cohort, rather than showing the inverse relationship that might be expected from Fe deficiency-related Mn accumulation. A small, threshold-dependent subgroup had relatively low hair Fe, relatively high hair Mn, and a reduced Fe:Mn ratio. These hair-based patterns should not be interpreted as evidence of systemic Fe deficiency, excessive Mn exposure, or a distinct clinical phenotype. Future studies should combine standardized hair analysis with established Fe-status biomarkers, direct measures of Mn exposure, dietary and supplementation data, appropriate control groups, and validated neurodevelopmental assessments.
BACKGROUND: Iron (Fe) and manganese (Mn) are essential metals that share several transport and regulatory pathways. Reduced Fe status may increase Mn uptake and retention, potentially increasing susceptibility to Mn-associated neurotoxicity. Children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) frequently have selective diets and micronutrient inadequacies, but the relationship between hair Fe and Mn has received limited attention.
OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to describe age- and sex-specific distributions of hair Fe and Mn in a large pediatric ASD cohort, evaluate the association between the two elements, and explore the occurrence of a subgroup with relatively low hair Fe and relatively high hair Mn.
METHODS: This retrospective cross-sectional study analyzed pre-existing hair trace-element records from a commercial laboratory for 2151 children and adolescents with an ASD diagnosis recorded in the laboratory datasets, including 1808 boys and 343 girls aged 0-18 years. Individual diagnostic records were unavailable, and the recorded diagnoses could not be independently verified. The laboratory-referred cohort was not population-representative, and no neurotypical control group was available. Hair Fe and Mn were measured by inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry and reported in mg/100 g hair. Distributions were summarized by sex and two-year age bands. Associations between natural-log-transformed Fe and Mn were examined using correlation and linear regression adjusted for age and sex. An exploratory low-Fe/high-Mn subgroup was defined using cohort-relative thresholds of hair Fe ≤ 0.7 mg/100 g and hair Mn ≥ 0.042 mg/100 g.
RESULTS: Median hair Fe was 0.8 mg/100 g, and median hair Mn was 0.024 mg/100 g. Concentrations showed little consistent variation across age groups or between boys and girls. Log-transformed Fe and Mn were strongly positively correlated (r = 0.66). In linear regression, log Fe was positively associated with log Mn (β = 1.22; 95% CI, 1.16-1.28; p < 0.001), and the association was unchanged after adjustment for age and sex. The model explained 44% of the variability in log Mn. The exploratory low-Fe/high-Mn subgroup comprised 62 participants (2.9%) and had a markedly lower median Fe:Mn ratio than the remaining cohort. More stringent sensitivity definitions identified progressively smaller subgroups.
CONCLUSIONS: Hair Fe and Mn concentrations were strongly and positively associated in this pediatric ASD cohort, rather than showing the inverse relationship that might be expected from Fe deficiency-related Mn accumulation. A small, threshold-dependent subgroup had relatively low hair Fe, relatively high hair Mn, and a reduced Fe:Mn ratio. These hair-based patterns should not be interpreted as evidence of systemic Fe deficiency, excessive Mn exposure, or a distinct clinical phenotype. Future studies should combine standardized hair analysis with established Fe-status biomarkers, direct measures of Mn exposure, dietary and supplementation data, appropriate control groups, and validated neurodevelopmental assessments.