Kodai Hamaoka, Tomoaki Kamiya, Kazushi Horita, Kousuke Shiwaku, Yasutoshi Ikeda, Yohei Okada, Makoto Emori, Atsushi Teramoto
Limited partial meniscectomy appeared to largely maintain the resultant force and tibiofemoral valgus angle of the DLM, whereas extensive resection was associated with reduced resultant force and a valgus shift. Tibial external rotation tended to increase progressively with increasing resection volume.
BACKGROUND: To evaluate the biomechanical characteristics of the discoid lateral meniscus (DLM) using a cadaveric specimen and clarify the effects of partial meniscectomy on the resultant force of the DLM and knee kinematics.
METHODS: Fresh-frozen cadaveric knee with a DLM was tested using a robotic system with six degrees of freedom. The knee was tested under 5-Nm valgus torque at 0°, 30°, 60° and 90° flexion to measure the resultant force and tibiofemoral valgus angle. Knee kinematics were evaluated during passive flexion-extension from 0 to 120° with a 10-N axial load. Five conditions were sequentially evaluated: intact, 25%, 50%, 75% partial lateral meniscectomy, and 100% lateral meniscectomy.
RESULTS: The resultant force of the DLM under 5-Nm valgus torque in each condition (intact/25%/50%/75% lateral meniscectomy) was 79.1/78.0/72.9/36.4 N at 0°; 61.6/57.0/54.9/21.6 N at 30°; 37.8/43.3/42.1/17.7 N at 60°; and 36.7/35.4/26.4/11.6 N at 90°, respectively. Additionally, the tibiofemoral valgus angle under 5-Nm valgus torque (intact/25%/50%/75% lateral meniscectomy/100% lateral meniscectomy) was 2.8/2.9/3.1/4.7/5.9° at 0°; 1.8/2.0/2.2/3.4/4.3° at 30°; 1.9/1.6/2.0/2.7/3.1° at 60°; and 3.4/3.7/4.1/6.2/7.1° at 90°, respectively. The tibiofemoral valgus angle under passive flexion-extension was -0.2/-0.1/0.3/1.0/2.8° at 0°; -1.3/-1.2/-1.0/0.1/0.8° at 30°; -2.0/-2.2/-2.0/-1.1/-0.8° at 60°; -1.9/-2.4/-2.2/-1.6/-1.0° at 90°; -1.2/-2.2/-2.2/-1.2/-0.6° at 120°, respectively. Finally, the external tibial rotation angle under passive flexion-extension in each condition was -8.8/-5.6/-3.7/-4.2/-1.3° at 0°; -7.1/-4.2/-2.4/-2.0/1.7° at 30°; -9.1/-5.7/-4.0/-3.2/-0.6° at 60°; -14.0/-9.7/-8.5/-7.8/-6.6° at 90°; and -18.5/-14.0/-12.7/-12.1/-10.9° at 120°, respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: Limited partial meniscectomy appeared to largely maintain the resultant force and tibiofemoral valgus angle of the DLM, whereas extensive resection was associated with reduced resultant force and a valgus shift. Tibial external rotation tended to increase progressively with increasing resection volume.