Peng Zhang, Delong Huang, Xingyu Lu, Haoshu Zhong, Chengzhen Liu, Hanyang Liu, Xiaodong Duan, Junhao Wu
By integrating single-arm pooled AUC estimates with formal head-to-head statistical comparisons, our study provides evidence-based support for plasma p-tau217 as the subtype with the most robust diagnostic performance across AD pathology and biological staging. Head-to-head analyses formally confirmed that p-tau217 significantly outperforms p-tau181 in Aβ positivity, Tau positivity, and biological staging.
BACKGROUND: Alzheimer's disease (AD) is the most common neurodegenerative disease and the most likely to lead to dementia. With the availability of the latest therapies, the need for Alzheimer's disease diagnosis is now gradually increasing. Whereas blood phosphorylated-tau (p-tau) has demonstrated excellent performance in the prediction and diagnosis of disease progression and Aβ positivity in AD, there are differences between different p-tau subtypes. Therefore, a pooled analysis of different blood p-tau subtypes is of more important clinical value.
METHOD: Relevant literature was screened by complete search in four databases, Pubmed, Embase, Cochrane Library and Scopus. Relevant data and AUC and their confidence intervals of the included literature were extracted and analyzed by classification according to p-tau subtypes. Quality assessment was performed using the QUADAS-2 tool.
RESULT: Our results reveal that p-tau217 performs better in the diagnostic performance in most stages of AD, which is consistent with the guidelines. However, our results concluded that p-tau217 has poorer diagnostic performance in the stages of cognitive unimpaired or less cognitively impaired, especially in the Aβ positivity diagnosis of SCD and CU. Head-to-head meta-analyses formally confirmed that p-tau217 significantly outperforms p-tau181 across AD dementia, Aβ positivity, tau positivity, and biological staging (all P < 0.05), whereas no significant difference was observed between p-tau231 and p-tau181.
CONCLUSION: By integrating single-arm pooled AUC estimates with formal head-to-head statistical comparisons, our study provides evidence-based support for plasma p-tau217 as the subtype with the most robust diagnostic performance across AD pathology and biological staging. Head-to-head analyses formally confirmed that p-tau217 significantly outperforms p-tau181 in Aβ positivity, Tau positivity, and biological staging.